St. James City Real Estate

St. James City Real Estate

Located in Lee County, Florida, St. James City is a charming waterfront community that offers a unique blend of natural beauty and small-town charm. Situated on the southern tip of Pine Island, this hidden gem is surrounded by the pristine waters of the Gulf of Mexico and the Caloosahatchee River.

St. James City is known for its laid-back and relaxed atmosphere, making it an ideal place for those seeking a peaceful and tranquil lifestyle. The area is home to a variety of outdoor recreational activities, including boating, fishing, and kayaking, thanks to its convenient access to the waterways. Residents can explore the stunning mangrove-lined canals and enjoy breathtaking sunsets while taking in the beauty of the surrounding nature.

Despite its tranquil setting, St. James City is also conveniently located near the bustling city of Cape Coral, offering residents easy access to a wide range of amenities, including shopping centers, restaurants, and entertainment options. Additionally, the area boasts excellent schools and healthcare facilities, making it an attractive choice for families and retirees alike.

Real estate options in St. James City range from charming waterfront cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, catering to a variety of budgets and preferences. Whether you're looking for a cozy retreat or a grand waterfront home, St. James City offers a plethora of options to suit every taste.

If you're seeking a serene and picturesque community with a laid-back lifestyle, St. James City is the perfect place to call home. With its natural beauty, waterfront living, and close-knit community, this hidden gem in Lee County, Florida, is a true paradise for those seeking a slice of paradise.

Newest Listings in St. James City

$4,250,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ St James Cove SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Welcome to an extraordinary waterfront estate where 3.4 acres, exceptional boating access and resort-style living come together in one remarkable property. With approximately 1,561 feet of deep-water canal frontage, commanding wide-water views and boating access leading out to the harbor and beyond, this is the kind of Southwest Florida estate that immediately stands apart. On 9/9/26, two parcels were legally combined to create an exceptionally unique waterfront footprint. The consolidation may also provide an opportunity for reduced property taxes. Enter through the gated entrance and follow a palm tree lined driveway to this custom Stearns-built residence, offered fully furnished. Inside, the dramatic great room rises approximately 21 feet, with a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, maple ceilings, cherry built-ins and an impressive open staircase. High-end craftsmanship and substantial architectural details carry throughout the home. A dedicated office and separate media room provide spaces designed specifically for working from home and relaxing or entertaining. Open up to the outside and the property transforms into a waterfront resort. The expansive lanai overlooks a zero-edge infinity pool and whirlpool, with a full outdoor kitchen, cypress ceilings, fire feature and generous entertaining areas. Watch manatees move through the canal, dolphins pass the dock and boats cruise by while entertaining poolside. From sunrise coffee by the water to sunset cocktails around the pool, this is a home built for the Florida lifestyle—where weekends feel like vacations and the hardest decision may be whether to take the boat or the golf cart. For boaters and anglers, a custom boathouse features a captain's walk and an 8,000-pound boat lift, while a 90-foot dock provides additional room for larger or visiting vessels. From here, explore Pine Island Sound, Sanibel, Captiva, Cayo Costa, Cabbage Key and the Gulf, with world-class fishing, waterfront restaurants and island destinations accessible by boat. The infrastructure behind the lifestyle is equally impressive, with impact windows, a whole-home and pool equipment generator, whole-house dehumidification system, 1,000-gallon buried propane tank, multi-zone air conditioning and ultra-high-speed internet connectivity. Even more impressive for a waterfront estate of this scale, current flood insurance is less than $1,700 annually. Two garages accommodate six vehicles, with high ceilings offering the potential to add lifts—an incredible setup for the car enthusiast, collector or anyone who needs room for the toys. Located just one mile from the heart of Saint James City, you can hop on your golf cart and enjoy local restaurants, bars, marinas and the laid-back island atmosphere that makes this community so unique. The real story here is difficult to duplicate: 3.4 acres, 1,561 feet of waterfront, serious boating infrastructure, a custom estate and resort-style outdoor living in one of Southwest Florida's most distinctive boating communities. After all, why own any old waterfront home when you can own one that is truly remembered?

2755 Cussell Drive, St James City
$1,649,900
Gulfhaven SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Welcome to Golden Palms Resort, an updated eight-unit waterfront retreat in the heart of St. James City! Set on an oversized double lot with approximately 161 feet of direct, no-bridge Gulf-access canal frontage, this rare income-producing property delivers the laid-back Pine Island lifestyle guests seek. All eight studio-style units have now been renovated and offers an open bedroom/living area, kitchen, private bath, and a balcony and/or patio—creating comfortable, turnkey accommodations with a bright coastal feel. A full-length waterfront dock provides exceptional boating access and room to enjoy the canal front setting, while the expansive deck is made for sunsets, entertaining, fishing stories, and dolphin watching. The property also features a 2025 metal roof, impact-resistant windows, mini-split A/C systems, two on-site coin-operated laundry sets, secured bike parking, maintenance and cleaning storage, ample parking, and a fenced pet-friendly yard. With four units historically leased annually and four used as vacation rentals, Golden Palms Resort offers flexibility for an investor, boutique hospitality operator, or owner seeking a waterfront compound with income potential. Seller financing may be available.

3226 Stringfellow Road, St James City
$225,000
Trailerhaven SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Welcome to your slice of paradise in the highly sought-after boating community of Trailerhaven! This direct waterfront property offers the ultimate Southwest Florida lifestyle with immediate water access right from your backyard. Equipped with a private boat dock and lift, you are just minutes away from exploring the world-class fishing, pristine beaches, and barrier islands of Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of Mexico.

3881 Areca Drive, St James City
$150,000
Gulfhaven Add SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Rare opportunity to build your custom waterfront home on a direct Gulf access canal with no fixed bridges. This vacant lot offers excellent potential for boating enthusiasts and those seeking a true island lifestyle. Enjoy quick access to open water, nearby marinas, local dining, and world-class fishing. A prime canvas to design and build your ideal coastal retreat.

3314 York Road, St James City
$2,390,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ St Jude Harbors SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Discover refined waterfront living in this distinctive 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom residence offering 3,850 square feet of thoughtfully designed interior space along a saltwater canal with access leading toward the Gulf. Blending elevated craftsmanship with meaningful upgrades, the home is anchored by a 2023 metal roof, powered hurricane shutters, and a spacious 3 car garage with overhead storage and built-in shelving. Inside, soaring ceilings create an immediate sense of scale, while elegant architectural arches, recessed lighting, and a polished, cohesive finish add warmth and sophistication throughout the main living spaces. The chef’s kitchen serves as a true centerpiece, appointed with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and two oversized islands, one with a sink and butcher-block surface and the other with breakfast-bar seating. Designed for both everyday living and elevated entertaining, the kitchen also features a 6-burner gas range with separate grill and flattop, pot filler, double ovens, a stainless hood, walk-in pantry, and built-in humidor. A striking double-sided fireplace gracefully separates the living and dining areas, creating an inviting backdrop for gatherings and quiet evenings alike. In the living room, a wet bar with utility sink and bar seating adds another layer of convenience, while doors open directly to the private courtyard retreat. Tile flooring enhances the main living areas, complemented by the warmth of wood flooring in the bedrooms. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a tray ceiling, fireplace, a large walk-in closet with built-ins, and two private balconies, one overlooking the water and the other overlooking the pool courtyard. Additional bedrooms feature built-in closets, with the rear bedroom enjoying its own waterfront balcony. Functional details continue with a dedicated laundry room with utility sink and cabinetry, wood stairs with decorative metal railing, and a unique pneumatic tube elevator. Outdoors, the property unfolds into a private resort-style setting. French doors lead to a covered and screened wraparound lanai with ceiling fans and lighting, creating a seamless extension of the home’s living space. The courtyard pool and spa, renovated by Aquatech Pools, are finished with marble pavers and enhanced by a water feature and built-in bench seating, creating a setting that feels both elegant and inviting. For boating enthusiasts, the waterfront infrastructure is exceptional. A composite dock wraps around the 10,000 pound covered boat lift and is accented by solar-powered lighting, making evenings on the water as effortless as they are memorable. Whether heading out for the day or returning at sunset, the dock is designed for smooth daily use. Ideally located near St. Jude Nature Trail, St. James Creek Preserve, marinas, dining, shopping, and everyday conveniences, this residence presents an exceptional opportunity to enjoy a polished waterfront lifestyle with comfort, style, and direct access to the water.

3605 Stabile Road, St James City
$200,000
St Jude Harbors SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Stop dreaming and start building! This is a nearly impossible-to-find TRIPLE LOT located in the heart of St. James City on the beautiful Pine Island. This expansive property offers significantly more frontage and buildable area than standard island lots, allowing for a substantial custom residence, multi-vehicle garage, and extensive outdoor living space. Plenty of space for a custom boat dock with GULF ACCESS!

3099 Cussell Drive, St James City
$449,999
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ St Jude Harbors SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Pictures available upon request. Welcome to your very own slice of island paradise in the heart of St. James City, where laid-back living meets endless waterfront adventure. This 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath home is situated on a large pie-shaped lot at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, offering a MASSIVE 158 feet of double seawall, a concrete boat dock, and direct access to the Gulf with no bridges—an ideal setup for boaters. The expansive lot provides ample room for a future pool, workshop, RV, boat, boat lift, or additional storage, giving you flexibility and space to make it your own.

3435 Sea Holly Lane, St James City
$399,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ St James City SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Pre-Construction. To be built. Pre-construction opportunity. To be built. Sale is for the lot with an existing structure, approved remodel permit with all fees PAID, and pool permit in hand with Design Concepts. Buyer need only submit an owner/builder affidavit with the building department or have their contractor provide required contractor information to the County. All remaining construction and development costs are the Buyer’s responsibility. The remodel permit took over a year to obtain, and the home is fully prepared for transformation. The existing structure requires remodel per the approved building plans, with the planned addition built on top of the existing concrete block walls—no costly house lifting required. The home has been completely gutted, concrete has been cut and hammered for new thickened footings, and all that remains is removal of the trusses and roof. Property includes two existing boat lifts (10,000 lb and 20,000 lb). The approved design features a beautiful open floor plan with vaulted ceilings, blending modern style with classic Old Florida appeal. Planned improvements include 2,075 sq ft of finished living space, a two-car garage, and approximately 1,215 sq ft of flex space on the lower level. Pool design does not encroach beneath the home, as shown in renderings. Enjoy a 10-minute boat ride to open water via the Philips Canal, with easy access to Sanibel, Captiva, and Fort Myers Beach. Located in the heart of golf cart–friendly St. James City, close to the general store, fish market, Galt Preserve, St. Jude Nature Trail, Calusa Heritage Trail, and Pine Island Sound Aquatic Preserve. Community amenities include Civic Association Park events, free concerts, biking and walking paths, tennis and pickleball courts, a heated community pool, playground, tiki restaurants, and weekly live entertainment. Come experience the laid-back island lifestyle you’ve been looking for.

2560 Baybreeze Street, St James City
$399,900
St James City SubDv. ⋅ 33956 Zip Code
Pre-construction opportunity. To be built. Sale is for the lot with an existing structure, approved remodel permit with all fees PAID, and pool permit in hand with Design Concepts. Buyer need only submit an owner/builder affidavit with the building department or have their contractor provide required contractor information to the County. All remaining construction and development costs are the Buyer’s responsibility. The remodel permit took over a year to obtain, and the home is fully prepared for transformation. The existing structure requires remodel per the approved building plans, with the planned addition built on top of the existing concrete block walls—no costly house lifting required. The home has been completely gutted, concrete has been cut and hammered for new thickened footings, and all that remains is removal of the trusses and roof. Property includes two existing boat lifts (10,000 lb and 20,000 lb). The approved design features a beautiful open floor plan with vaulted ceilings, blending modern style with classic Old Florida appeal. Planned improvements include 2,075 sq ft of finished living space, a two-car garage, and approximately 1,215 sq ft of flex space on the lower level. Pool design does not encroach beneath the home, as shown in renderings. Enjoy a 10-minute boat ride to open water via the Philips Canal, with easy access to Sanibel, Captiva, and Fort Myers Beach. Located in the heart of golf cart–friendly St. James City, close to the general store, fish market, Galt Preserve, St. Jude Nature Trail, Calusa Heritage Trail, and Pine Island Sound Aquatic Preserve. Community amenities include Civic Association Park events, free concerts, biking and walking paths, tennis and pickleball courts, a heated community pool, playground, tiki restaurants, and weekly live entertainment. Come experience the laid-back island lifestyle you’ve been looking for.

2560 Baybreeze Street, St James City
Start Your Search